Posted by Lord Voodoo on May 06, 1999 at 15:08:15:
In Reply to: Re: Newsflash!!~~~Emotional Rescue is better than Voodoo Lounge posted by Maxlugar '99 on May 06, 1999 at 15:01:15:
: Hi!
: Using my patented "less is more theory" VL wins big.
: Take the 5 worst songs away from VL (make it 10 songs
: just like ER) and you get an
: 8.1 average that clobbers ER's 7.54.
: Less is more.
: Thanks!!
: Maxy
:
Yes but unfortunately for your theory, the album does have those songs. You could argue that if you took the best song from each album and threw out everything else, ER still wins in my book. If you take the top 5 songs and threw out the rest, ER still wins. But since that is a nonsensical way of rating albums, ei by rating only the good songs, then we shouldn't do that. So lets just compare the albums as is