Posted by Keno on October 24, 1999 at 23:31:00:
In Reply to: Re: If EXILE had been only ten songs.... posted by Sir Stonesalot on October 24, 1999 at 10:20:13:
:No offense Keno, but that's where your album rating system breaks down. It fails to take into consideration the objective of the whole album, as opposed to each individual song.........
No offense taken. I agree there are different ways to look at most Stones albums, just don't feel my rating system breaks down at all, perhaps it is lacking this one ingredient that you bring up. But I think that way of looking at an album would call for a second, separate rating. Of cause this way of rating Stones albums would not work at all with all the early releases before Aftermath since the Stones did not choose what songs would be on their separate US and UK releases. That was more a marketing decision by others on what songs would appeal to either country.
Post a Followup